Ernie's Pizzeria

Enjoy authentic New Haven-style pizza at Ernie's Pizzeria located at 1279 Whalley Ave, New Haven. Savor delicious pies with bacon, sausage, meatballs, gluten-free options, cherry peppers, and more. Call +1 203-387-3362 today!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Ernie's Pizzeria

Experience the finest dining

Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria

Ernie's Pizzeria stands as a cornerstone of New Haven's culinary scene. Located at 1279 Whalley Ave, this pizza restaurant radiates warmth and community spirit. It’s a favorite spot for locals craving the distinct flavors of New Haven-style pizza. Diners appreciate the inviting atmosphere, making it perfect for families, friends, or a casual night out. The menu brims with fresh, high-quality ingredients, capturing both classic and inventive toppings.

From savory bacon to zesty cherry peppers, each pizza tells a flavorful story. Whether you're stopping by for a slice or hosting a gathering, Ernie's serves as a delicious hub for pizza lovers.

Ernie's Pizzeria boasts an array of features that elevate the dining experience. First, the menu highlights the New Haven pizza tradition, showcasing unique topping combinations like clam and meatball that you won't find everywhere. For those with dietary restrictions, gluten-free options are readily available. The restaurant operates with efficient service, ensuring that even during peak hours, guests enjoy attentiveness without long waits. Additionally, the casual and friendly ambiance creates a welcoming space for all ages.

With a selection of beer and wine, diners can pair their meal to enhance the flavors. During busy times, the vibe buzzes with energetic chatter, reflecting the community’s love for great food. Overall, Ernie's provides a satisfying and approachable dining environment.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

1279 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06515, United States

Phone

+1 203-387-3362

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria
Ernie's Pizzeria

Ernie's Pizzeria stands out not just for its incredible pies but for its strong ties to the local community. Founded in a city known for its pizza, Ernie's embraces the traditions of New Haven-style pizza while putting its unique spin on beloved classics. The owner is passionate about offering a menu filled with fresh ingredients and bold flavors, emphasizing local sourcing whenever possible.

Ernie's crafts each pizza with care, using a homemade dough that rises to perfection and a signature tomato sauce that ties the flavors together beautifully. Signature menu items like the clam pizza and the meatball pie showcase creativity while honoring local preferences. Diners appreciate the attentive staff, who remember regulars and their preferences, adding a personal touch to their experience.

Special events and community gatherings often take place, transforming the pizzeria into a hub of social interaction. Moreover, the establishment engages with nearby schools, offering discounts to students and organizing charity events that support local causes. With its combination of quality, community involvement, and a passionate approach to food, Ernie's Pizzeria remains an essential part of New Haven's vibrant dining landscape.

Ernie's Pizzeria

The exterior of Ernie's Pizzeria is inviting, with a classic, nostalgic look that hints at its long-standing history in New Haven. Situated along Whalley Avenue, it benefits from visibility and accessibility, making it a convenient stop for hungry passersby. The outdoor seating area captures the essence of community dining, where visitors can enjoy a meal al fresco while soaking in the lively atmosphere. The vibrant signs and welcoming entrance create a warm invitation for everyone. Inside, the vibe is relaxed yet bustling, filled with the aroma of fresh pizza baking in the oven and the chatter of satisfied customers. Whether dining in or taking out, the ambiance complements the restaurant's dedication to serving delightful pizza.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday3-10 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday3-10 PM
  • Wednesday3-10 PM
  • Thursday3-10 PM
  • Friday11 AM-11 PM
  • Saturday12-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Been hitting the local pizza hot spots every weekend. This week was Ernies, in Westville (New Haven) I haven't had an Ernies Pie in over 20 years, but remember it as being very good. It appears my memory serves me correctly.. it was excellent! Today, got a large, half bacon, half sausage and a small white clam, no cheese (except some grated cheese). Both pies came out quickly. The bacon/sausage pie had the usual New Haven Abeetz char.. EXCELLENT! The white clam, just a little char, but also perfect. Both pies crust was excellent and tasty, sauce was excellent and ingrediants were of high quality. Definitely give Ernies a try... u ou won't be disappointed.

J
J V.

This is the #143rd restaurant I have dined at in New Haven. They have a small team and a small menu, but delivered it perfectly. There is an open kitchen where you can see the dough being made into a pizza. The bread is stickier compared with other apizza places in town. They also pair it with a classic Foxon Park soda.

X
Xiao Y.

Great spot! Delicious pizza and always very welcoming staff. Perhaps a bit pricey compared to a few others in the area, but well worth dropping the extra bucks for. The way I look at instead of going to a mediocre spot once a week (pizza heaven) go here like once a month then. Also, I HIGHLY recommend getting fresh garlic added to whatever pie you get. Automatically makes you say mama Mia that's good!

R
Remote

Run, don't walk, to Ernie's, both because it's so good and because you'll need to burn some calories to make up for all of the delicious pizza you're going to eat. There was zero wait on a Saturday night even though this place deserves a line out the door. We got a pepperoni mozzarella pie and a hot cherry peppers mozzarella pie. Both were fantastic. Perfectly crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and delicious toppings. Our server was attentive and kind. 100% recommend.

M
Mike S.

I've never once been disappointed by a pie from Ernie's--a real gem in Westville, and hands-down the best pizza you can find without heading all way downtown. Staff is always warm, friendly, and accommodating as they can be. Parking can be tight at peak hours, but once you're inside--you're in for a real treat!

J
JP M.

Pizza was amazing! We got 3 pies all cooked to perfection. My favorite was the mozzarella with hot cherry peppers. Waitstaff was fantastic! She was super helpful & efficient.

E
Emily I.